Why are Shock Collars Still Being Used?

Return to blog

It could be the fact that they have been around for quite some time. Since the late 1960's dog owners have had the option of purchasing these collars. Albeit in their nascent beginnings, they were primarily bought and used to train hunting dogs, their popularity grew among dog owners, finding them useful for other training purposes.

The fact that they are not only still around, but have technologically evolved, with more retailers selling them, it does beg the question: with so many other options out there to address behavioral problems with our furry family members, why are shock collars still being used?

In a recent article published in the Washington Post   this issue is again being surfaced with clear lines being drawn between those for and against using a shock collar. In other developed countries such as Quebec, Wales, and parts of Australia the shock collar has been banned completely, with Canada, Scotland, and Britain considering it. In the U.S. shock collars are unregulated and far from being banned. This could very well change, as a growing number of people are beginning to speak out against the use of these collars resulting in a recent ordinance adopted by Alexandria, VA which limits their use on public property. Not a complete ban, but viewed by its proponents as a step in the right direction. And if Russel Upol, interviewee for the article, is successful with his petition to ban them in the state of Oklahoma this will be another win for those opposed to this type of training. In Russell's case, however, things took a bit of a turn. He did some research, talked to a few people who actually used shock collars on their animals and decided that an all-out ban on shock collars might not be the right way to go. He softened his position a bit pushing instead for mandatory training for folks who wish to use shock collars on their dogs.

Often in some cases the answer to a question is easier than one might think. So why are shock collars still being used, well maybe it is as simple as, “because they can.” I don't think those people who decide to use shock collars are doing so with the intent to be mean or cruel to their pet. I think it is a matter of convenience for some as they are readily available, while others find the use of “shock” and the efficacy of these collars are strong enough to work on their dogs because nothing else has. At the very least I think we all owe it to our four-legged friends we share this planet with that at the very least we need to keep the conversation going. Reminding people that shock collars are not for every dog and that other options are available and should be acknowledged before considering this method of behavior modification. Even though Russel Upol was only able to garner 700 of the 50,000 signatures he needed for his petition, “for now,” he said, he's satisfied with having brought attention to the collars.

Recent Articles

Another Satisfied Customer

Another Satisfied Customer

There's nothing better than when someone sends us a review letting us know how one of our products helped change their life for the better. It's a nice reminder that our work is doing something good in the world.
The Shocking Truth About Shock Collars

The Shocking Truth About Shock Collars

Shock collars can be painful and harmful to your dog and there are other more humane options available to train your best friend to not bark so much.
3 Ways Dog Barking Can Ruin Your Day

3 Ways Dog Barking Can Ruin Your Day

Dog barking in the middle of the night can ruin your day. Studies show that If you don't get enough sleep you might be feeling ruff the next day. The 3:00am wake up call It's the middle of the night and bark, bark, bark your neighbor's dog is at it again. Has this happened to you? If the answer is yes, you know how frustrating it can be to repeatedly not get a good night's sleep because your neighbor's are rude or just they don't get it. What can you do to stop the dog barking? Wish you could just...

You love your dog. The constant barking, not so much...

You love your dog. The constant barking, not so much...

No matter how much you love your dog. It can be frustrating when they bark at each and every little sound or passerby. The Dog Silencer® is a safe, humane and effective way to automatically train your dog to stop barking. How's it work? When the Dog Silencer detects barking it immediately sends a high-pitched sound heard only by them. This sound is designed to simply “irritate” your dog. We compare it to someone dragging their fingernails on a black board. Any dog that's within hearing range of the Dog Silencer will hear the bark deterring sound. Using this proven...

Q&A: Will BarkWise Collars Fit My Small, 5-Pound Dog?

Q&A: Will BarkWise Collars Fit My Small, 5-Pound Dog?

Q: Will the collars be too big for my small 5-pound dog? A: The BarkWise collars fit dogs that are 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes ranging from 6–24″. They are lightweight at only 2 ounces, but for a small 5-pound dog, they have proven to be too big. That doesn't mean that we don't have a solution for you! The Dog Silencer and OnGuard do not require that your dog wear a collar, so it works for any dogs – no matter how small! The Dog Silencer® is a stationary device. Place it in the same room –...